Ideas

How to brainstorm on your own: 9 techniques that work solo

You don't need a room full of people and a pack of sticky notes. Some of the best brainstorming happens alone, as long as you keep having ideas and judging them as two separate jobs.

By the Offo teamUpdated 7 min read

The short answer

To brainstorm on your own, set a clear question, give yourself a time limit and a target number, and write every idea down fast without judging it. Use a technique such as a question burst, SCAMPER or Crazy 8s to push past the obvious ideas, then step away before you choose. Working alone isn't a handicap: studies of brainstorming have long found that people working individually tend to produce more ideas than the same people brainstorming out loud as a group.

  • Start with a question, not a topic.
  • Generate first, judge later.
  • Aim for quantity: the good ideas usually come after the obvious ones.
  • Sleep on it, then choose.

Is brainstorming alone better than in a group?

Often, yes. Brainstorming as a group method was popularised by the advertising executive Alex Osborn, most famously in his book Applied Imagination (1953). Decades of research since have found that groups talking together usually produce fewer ideas than the same number of people working alone and pooling their lists afterwards.

One big reason is what psychologists call production blocking. In a group, only one person can talk at a time, so everyone else is waiting, forgetting, or quietly deciding their idea isn't worth saying (Diehl & Stroebe, 1987).

Solo brainstorming has a weakness of its own: nobody builds on your ideas or challenges them. The techniques below deal with the first problem, and there's a fix for the second at the end.

Before you start: set up the question

  • Make it a question. “How might we get more people to our Saturday market?” works better than “market ideas”. Questions invite answers.
  • Make it specific. Who, where, by when? The narrower the question, the more useful the ideas.
  • Set a time and a number. Twenty ideas in ten minutes is a good default. The number pushes you past the obvious; the timer stops you polishing.
  • Keep the two jobs apart. Generate now, judge later. Mixing them kills ideas before they're fully formed.

Nine techniques that work on your own

1. The brain dump

Write everything down, fast, for five minutes: good ideas, silly ones, half-sentences. The first handful will be obvious. Keep going, because the interesting ones usually turn up once you've emptied out the expected.

2. The question burst

Instead of listing answers, list questions. Hal Gregersen of MIT designed the question burst for groups (Gregersen, 2018): set a four-minute timer and write as many questions about the problem as you can, aiming for at least fifteen, without answering any of them. It works just as well alone. Then pick the question that surprises you most, and brainstorm answers to that instead.

3. The worst possible idea

Brainstorm how to make the problem worse. How could you guarantee nobody comes to the market? No signs, everything overpriced, open only in the rain… Then flip each bad idea into its opposite. It's easier to be creative when you're not trying to be right.

4. SCAMPER

A checklist for changing an existing idea, which Bob Eberle distilled from Osborn's earlier prompts: Substitute, Combine, Adapt, Modify, Put to another use, Eliminate, Reverse. Run your current idea through each word and write at least one variation for each.

5. Crazy 8s

Draw eight boxes and sketch eight different ideas in eight minutes, one per box. The technique comes from the design sprint process described in Sprint (Knapp, Zeratsky & Kowitz, 2016). A minute per idea leaves no room for polish, which is the point. (No drawing skills needed: see our guide to sketching to think.)

6. Add a constraint

Constraints force new angles. What if it had to cost nothing? Be ready by Friday? Work for a seven-year-old? Take one constraint at a time and brainstorm again.

7. Borrow from somewhere else

Ask how someone in a completely different field would solve it. How would a library run your market? A theme park? A dating app? Analogies drag in ideas you'd never reach from inside your own world.

8. Brainwrite in rounds

In groups, brainwriting means writing ideas down silently and passing them on for others to build on. Alone, do it in rounds: write a batch, leave it for an hour or a day, then come back and build on each idea as if a stranger had written it.

9. Change where you're thinking

Get up. In a series of Stanford experiments, people came up with more creative uses for everyday objects while walking than while sitting, and the boost lingered after they sat back down (Oppezzo & Schwartz, 2014). Take the question for a walk, then write down whatever comes back with you.

Your pageMore people at the Saturday market?
– live music
– a kids' corner
– loyalty stamps
– move it to the square

Offo writes back“Move it to the square” is a different kind of idea from the other three. They make the market nicer for people who already come; the square puts it in front of people who don't. Which problem have you actually got? If it's footfall, could you trial the square for one Saturday before anything else?

An illustrative example: a quick list, and the kind of reply Offo writes back.

After the burst: how to choose

  1. Step away. Even a night's sleep changes how ideas look. The psychologist Graham Wallas called this stage incubation.
  2. Cluster. Group similar ideas together. Clusters often point to what you actually care about.
  3. Pick three. Not one. Three gives you options and something to compare.
  4. Pressure-test the favourite. Write down what would have to be true for it to work, and find the weakest link. Our guide to pressure-testing an idea shows how.
Try this

Set a four-minute timer and write fifteen questions about a problem you're stuck on, without answering any of them. Circle the one that surprises you most, and spend the next ten minutes on that.

Getting a second mind in the room

The missing ingredient in solo brainstorming is someone who says “yes, and…” or “hang on, why?”. You can bring that back without the downsides of a group: a friend who'll reply to a photo of your page, or an AI that pushes rather than produces.

With AI, the order matters. Ask it for ideas first and you'll anchor on its list. Generate your own first, then ask it to question, combine or extend them. (More on that in our guide to using AI as a thinking partner.)

Offo, a notebook for iPad that writes back, is built for that second step. Brainstorm on the page as you normally would, then send it, and Offo replies beside your ideas in handwriting: a question you skipped, another route, or the one idea it would try first.

Questions people ask

What is the best brainstorming technique?

There isn't a single best technique, but separating idea generation from judgement matters more than any particular method. For quick results on your own, try a five-minute brain dump followed by a question burst.

How long should a brainstorming session be?

Short. Ten to twenty minutes of generating ideas is plenty for one question. Take a break before you start choosing between them.

Is brainstorming alone effective?

Yes. Research since the 1980s has found that people working alone often produce more ideas than the same number of people brainstorming out loud as a group, partly because in a group only one person can speak at a time.

How do I brainstorm when I'm stuck?

Change the question. Brainstorm the worst possible idea, add a constraint, or ask how someone in a completely different field would solve it. Or go for a walk and take the question with you.

Sources

  1. Osborn, A. F. (1953). Applied Imagination: Principles and Procedures of Creative Thinking. Scribner.
  2. Diehl, M. & Stroebe, W. (1987). Productivity loss in brainstorming groups: toward the solution of a riddle. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 53(3), 497–509. doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.53.3.497
  3. Gregersen, H. (2018). Better brainstorming. Harvard Business Review, March–April 2018. hbr.org/2018/03/better-brainstorming
  4. Eberle, B. (1971). SCAMPER: Games for Imagination Development. D.O.K. Publishers.
  5. Knapp, J., Zeratsky, J. & Kowitz, B. (2016). Sprint: How to Solve Big Problems and Test New Ideas in Just Five Days. Simon & Schuster.
  6. Oppezzo, M. & Schwartz, D. L. (2014). Give your ideas some legs: the positive effect of walking on creative thinking. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition, 40(4), 1142–1152. doi.org/10.1037/a0036577
  7. Wallas, G. (1926). The Art of Thought. Jonathan Cape.

Brainstorm with a second mind on the page

Offo is a notebook for iPad and Apple Pencil. Get your ideas down, send them, and Offo writes back with a question, another route or the one it would try first.