Decisions
How to make a big decision: think it through on paper
Big decisions are hard to hold in your head. There are too many parts, and they keep moving. Put them on a page and they sit still long enough to think about.
The short answer
To make a big decision, write it down. Name the real question, widen your options beyond “yes or no”, list what matters to you and weigh each option against it, then check your favourite from a distance: how will it look in ten months or ten years, and what would make it go wrong? If the decision is easy to reverse, decide faster and learn as you go.
- Name the real decision, not the first one that comes to mind.
- Give yourself at least three options.
- Weigh them on paper, over more than one sitting.
- Ask whether you can undo it. If you can, move faster.
Why big decisions feel impossible in your head
A big decision has more moving parts than your working memory can hold: money, people, timing, what you want now, what you'll want later. So your mind does what it does with too much information. It goes round in circles, gives too much weight to whatever you thought of last, and wakes you at 3am to go round again.
Paper breaks the loop. Once the parts are written down they stop moving. You can see them all at once, compare them fairly, and notice which one you keep coming back to. (Our guide to thinking on paper explains why that works.)
Step 1: Name the real decision
The first version of a decision is often the wrong one. “Should I quit my job?” might really be “How do I stop dreading Mondays?”, and that question has more than one answer.
Write your decision at the top of a page, then ask “why?” once or twice. If the answer changes the question, write the new one underneath. Decide that one.
Step 2: Widen your options
In Decisive (2013), Chip and Dan Heath point out that many bad decisions start with a narrow frame: “whether or not” instead of “which of these”. A yes-or-no question hides every option that isn't on the table.
Try their vanishing options test: imagine none of the options you're considering were available. What would you do then? Whatever you write down is a new option. Aim for at least three before you start weighing anything.
Step 3: Weigh it on paper
In 1772, the scientist Joseph Priestley asked Benjamin Franklin for advice about a job offer. Franklin replied with a method he called “moral or prudential algebra”. Divide a sheet of paper into two columns, Pro and Con, and over three or four days jot down reasons as they occur to you. Then weigh them: where a reason on one side roughly balances one on the other, strike both out, until you can see where the balance lies.
Two details make it better than a quick list. Franklin spread it over several days, so the reasons weren't just the ones that happened to be loudest that afternoon. And he weighed reasons rather than counting them: one heavy reason can outweigh five light ones.
When you're choosing between several options, a simple table does the same job. Score each option from 1 to 5 against what matters, and multiply by how much it matters:
| What matters (weight) | Stay | New job in Leeds | Go freelance |
|---|---|---|---|
| Time with family (×3) | 4 | 2 | 3 |
| Money (×2) | 3 | 5 | 2 |
| Learning (×2) | 2 | 4 | 5 |
| Security (×1) | 5 | 4 | 1 |
| Weighted total | 27 | 28 | 24 |
Notice what the numbers did there. They didn't make the decision: 27 against 28 is a coin toss. They showed you it's a close call, and pointed at what's really deciding it. Here, it's time with family against money. Use the scores to start the conversation with yourself, not to end it.
Step 4: Check it from a distance
Up close, the short term shouts. Two quick checks give the long term a voice.
- 10/10/10. Suzy Welch's rule of thumb: how will you feel about this choice in ten minutes, ten months and ten years? It's a quick way to tell a painful moment from a lasting mistake.
- The regret test. Jeff Bezos has described imagining himself at 80 when deciding whether to leave a steady job to start Amazon, and asking which choice he'd regret. Regret is a surprisingly good compass for big, personal decisions.
Step 5: Can you undo it?
In his 2015 letter to Amazon shareholders, Bezos also split decisions into two kinds. One-way doors are hard or impossible to reverse, and deserve slow, careful thought. Two-way doors can be undone: if you don't like what's on the other side, you walk back through.
Many decisions are two-way doors dressed up as one-way doors. You can move back, change jobs again, stop the course, close the shop. If yours is reversible, set a date to review it, make the call and learn from what happens. Save the slow, careful process for the decisions that really can't be undone.
Step 6: Imagine it went wrong
Before you commit, run a quick pre-mortem: imagine it's a year later and the decision turned out badly, and write down why. You're not looking for reasons to back out. You're looking for things to prepare for. There's more on this in our guide to pressure-testing an idea.
Write your decision at the top of a page tonight, and just one column of reasons. Add to it tomorrow and the day after, the way Franklin did. On the third day, strike out the reasons that balance, and see what's left.
Talking it through
Some decisions get clearer the moment you say them out loud to someone who asks good questions: a friend, a mentor, a journal. The best of them don't tell you what to do. They notice what you keep circling back to.
Offo, a notebook for iPad that writes back, can be that kind of listener on the page. Write out your decision, your columns and your half-formed reasons, then send it. Offo replies beside it in handwriting, often with the question you've been avoiding. It won't make the decision for you, and that's the point.
Your pageTake the job in Leeds?
PRO: more money, new team, the city
CON: friends here, the allotment, further from Mum
Offo writes backYou've underlined “Mum” twice and nothing else. That makes me think this isn't really a pros-and-cons question. Is the real question how often you'd want to see her, and whether Leeds makes that harder? If it's a couple of hours on the train, is it as big a con as it feels?
Questions people ask
What is the best way to make a difficult decision?
Write it down. Name the real question, come up with at least three options, weigh them against what matters to you over more than one sitting, and check your choice from a distance with the 10/10/10 rule or a regret test.
What is Benjamin Franklin's decision-making method?
Franklin's “moral or prudential algebra”, described in a 1772 letter to Joseph Priestley, is a weighed list of pros and cons: two columns on a sheet of paper, filled in over several days, with reasons of equal weight on each side struck out until you can see where the balance lies.
What is the 10/10/10 rule?
A decision check popularised by Suzy Welch: ask how you'll feel about a choice in ten minutes, ten months and ten years. It helps separate short-term discomfort from long-term consequences.
What's a one-way door decision?
A decision that's hard or impossible to reverse, as opposed to a two-way door, which you can undo. The terms come from Jeff Bezos's 2015 letter to Amazon shareholders: take one-way doors slowly and carefully, and two-way doors quickly.
Sources
- Franklin, B. (1772). Letter to Joseph Priestley, 19 September 1772. Founders Online, National Archives
- Heath, C. & Heath, D. (2013). Decisive: How to Make Better Choices in Life and Work. Crown Business.
- Welch, S. (2009). 10-10-10: A Life-Transforming Idea. Scribner.
- Bezos, J. (2016). 2015 Letter to Shareholders. Amazon.com, Inc.
- Klein, G. (2007). Performing a project premortem. Harvard Business Review, September 2007. hbr.org/2007/09/performing-a-project-premortem