Thinking on paper

How to keep an idea notebook you'll actually use

Everyone has ideas in the shower. The people who do something with them have somewhere to put them, and a habit of coming back.

By the Offo teamUpdated 5 min read

The short answer

An idea notebook works when capture is instant, review is regular, and every idea you keep leaves with a next question. Write ideas down the moment they arrive, one per page, with a line on why they excited you. Look back once a week. For each idea that still interests you, write the one question that would move it forward, and go and answer it.

  • One notebook, not five apps.
  • One idea per page, dated, with a “why this excites me” line.
  • A fifteen-minute review every week.
  • Every idea you keep gets a next question.

Why ideas vanish

Good ideas rarely turn up on schedule. In The Art of Thought (1926), the psychologist Graham Wallas described four stages of creative thinking: preparation (working on a problem), incubation (stepping away from it), illumination (the idea arrives) and verification (checking it works). The shower, the walk, the moment before sleep: that's incubation paying off.

The trouble is that illumination doesn't last. The idea arrives complete and vivid, and twenty minutes later you remember that you had one, but not what it was. An idea notebook exists to catch it in between.

It also fixes a quieter problem. Ideas that stay in your head never get tested. On paper, they can be questioned, combined and improved, or let go.

Set up your idea notebook

  • Use one place. Ideas scattered across notes apps, voice memos and the backs of envelopes are ideas you'll never see side by side. Pick one notebook and make it home.
  • One idea per page. Give each idea room to grow. A page each means you can add to it later without untangling it from the one before.
  • Date it and title it. A short title you'll recognise in six months, and the date.
  • Write why it excites you. One line: “Because I'm tired of…” or “Because nobody's done…”. That line is what you'll need when the idea looks flat next week.

Capture in seconds

The best capture method is the one with the least friction. If it takes more than a few seconds to start writing, you'll tell yourself you'll remember. You won't.

  • Keep your notebook one tap away: on your Home Screen, or on your desk.
  • Scribble, sketch, abbreviate. Capture isn't the time for neat.
  • Don't judge while you capture. Bad ideas often point at good ones.
  • If you're away from your notebook, send yourself a one-line message and copy it in later.

The weekly review

Capture without review is just hoarding. Once a week, give your notebook fifteen minutes. Go through the new pages and ask three questions of each:

  1. Does it still excite me? If not, mark it and move on. No guilt.
  2. What's the smallest way to test it? A conversation, a sketch, a one-page mock-up, a weekend.
  3. What question would move it forward? Write that question on the page.

Then mark each idea grow, keep or let go. Only the “grow” pile needs anything from you this week.

Your pageShower thought:
a tool library for our street?

Offo writes backA street tool library is lovely, and ladders and drills are exactly the things people use twice a year. The tricky part is usually the returns, not the lending. Who on your street already lends things out? They might be your first librarian. Could you start with just their shed and a clipboard?

An illustrative example: a quick idea, and the kind of next question Offo writes back.

Growing an idea

Growing an idea is mostly a matter of asking it better questions:

  • Who is it for, specifically? Name a person.
  • What's the smallest version that would still be worth doing?
  • What would have to be true for it to work? (Our guide to pressure-testing an idea covers this.)
  • What's the first thing you could do this week?

Some people keep a daily writing habit alongside their idea notebook. Julia Cameron's “morning pages”, from The Artist's Way (1992), are three pages of longhand, stream-of-consciousness writing done first thing every morning. They aren't an idea notebook, but they're a dependable way to shake ideas loose.

Letting ideas go

A notebook full of ideas you didn't pursue isn't a failure. Most ideas are stepping stones to better ones. When you let one go, write a line on why. Six months later, “too expensive for now” or “someone's already doing it well” is useful to know, and sometimes the reason has changed.

Try this

Find three ideas you've had this year, wherever they're scattered, and give each its own page with a date, a title and a “why this excites me” line. Next week, review them. That's your notebook started.

A notebook that writes back

The hardest part of keeping an idea notebook is the review, because it's you reviewing your own ideas, and you're usually either too kind or too harsh.

Offo is a notebook for iPad that writes back. Capture an idea the way you would on paper, then send it, and Offo replies on the page with a question, a different angle or a small next step. The conversation stays next to the idea, so when you come back next week, you can see exactly where you left off. It's the notebook and the second opinion in one place.

Questions people ask

What should I write in an idea notebook?

Every idea that makes you curious, however small or unlikely, with the date, a short title and one line on why it excites you. Sketches, questions and half-thoughts all count.

Should I keep an idea notebook on paper or digitally?

Whichever you'll open fastest. Paper is quick and distraction-free. A digital notebook on an iPad can be searched, backed up and taken everywhere, and some, like Offo, can write back to you.

How do I stop losing ideas?

Make capture instant and keep everything in one place. Most lost ideas are lost in the few minutes between having them and finding somewhere to write them down.

What do I do with all the ideas I've written down?

Review them once a week. Keep the ones that still excite you, write the next question for each, and let the rest go with a note on why.

Sources

  1. Wallas, G. (1926). The Art of Thought. Jonathan Cape.
  2. Cameron, J. (1992). The Artist's Way: A Spiritual Path to Higher Creativity. Tarcher/Putnam.

Give your next idea a reply

Offo is a notebook for iPad and Apple Pencil. Write an idea down, send it, and Offo writes back on the page with the question that moves it on.