Writing and speaking
How to plan a talk or essay before you write a word
The hard part of a talk or an essay isn't the writing. It's knowing what you're trying to say. Work that out on one page first, and the writing gets much easier.
The short answer
Plan a talk or essay by deciding your one main point before anything else, then sketching the few steps that get your audience there. Write the point as a single sentence, list the questions your audience will ask in the order they'll ask them, and turn those questions into your sections. Give each section one concrete example, then say the whole plan out loud in a minute before you start drafting.
- One sentence you want your audience to remember.
- Their questions, in order, become your sections.
- One example for each point.
- Test it out loud before you draft.
Start with one sentence
Before outlines, slides or opening lines, answer one question: if your audience remembers a single sentence, what should it be?
Write it at the top of a page. Not a topic (“repair cafés”) but a claim (“Our town should fix things before it recycles them”). If you can't write it yet, that isn't a writing problem. It's a thinking problem, and the rest of this page will help.
Everything in the talk or essay should support that sentence, explain it, or deal with the best objection to it. Anything else is a candidate for cutting.
Know who you're talking to
The same point needs a different route for different people. On the same page, jot down:
- What they already know, and what they believe.
- What they care about. Why would they listen?
- What they'll object to, or be confused by.
- What you want them to do, think or feel afterwards.
Sketch the shape on one page
Most good talks and essays use one of a handful of shapes. Pick the one that suits your point and your audience.
| Shape | How it goes | Good for |
|---|---|---|
| Answer first | Your main point, then the reasons and evidence for it. Barbara Minto's Pyramid Principle, developed at McKinsey, is the classic version. | Busy audiences, reports, business writing |
| Problem, then solution | What's wrong, why it matters, what to do about it | Proposals, pitches, persuasive essays |
| Story | A person, a problem, what happened, what changed | Keynotes, personal essays, opening a talk |
| What is, what could be | Move back and forth between how things are and how they could be, then ask for action. Nancy Duarte calls this the “sparkline”. | Talks that ask people to change |
| Question and answers | A question, the possible answers, and your verdict | Academic essays, explainers |
Sketch it as boxes on a page rather than a document outline. Boxes are easy to move around; bullet points harden too early. (Our guide to sketching to think has more shapes to try.)
Turn your audience's questions into sections
Here's a trick that works for almost any piece: write down the questions your audience will ask, in the order they'll ask them. For a talk proposing a repair café, that might be:
- What's a repair café?
- Why would people bother?
- Who does the fixing?
- What would it cost the town?
- What do you need from us?
Those questions are your sections, in order. You'll never have to wonder what comes next, because the audience is telling you.
Find one example for each point
Abstract points slide off; examples stick. For each section, find one concrete thing: a person, a number, a before-and-after, a story from your own life. If you can't find an example for a point, ask whether it's really a point.
Your pageTalk: why our town needs a repair café
1. less waste
2. brings people together
3. teaches skills
Offo writes backThree good reasons, but they read like three separate talks. Which one would make the council say yes? If it's waste, lead with a number: how much does the town throw away in a week? The other two can be the bonus, not the case. What's the one sentence you want them to repeat afterwards?
Test the plan before you write
- Say it in a minute. Explain the whole talk or essay out loud in sixty seconds, from the plan. Where you stumble is where the plan is weak.
- Find a sceptic. Ask someone who'll disagree what they'd object to, and put the best objection into the plan.
- Check the ending. Does it land back on your one sentence? It should.
Before your next talk or essay, give yourself one page and fifteen minutes: your one sentence at the top, your audience's questions down the side, one example beside each. Then say it out loud to the kettle.
Talks and essays: what's different
The planning is the same. The delivery isn't.
- A talk is heard once. Listeners can't flip back, so repeat your main point, signpost where you are (“second…”), and use fewer points than feels natural. Three is plenty.
- An essay can be re-read. Readers can handle more steps and more evidence, but they'll also notice every gap in the logic, so the reasoning between points has to be tight.
- Talks need moments; essays need momentum. A talk wants a story, a surprising number or a question to the room. An essay wants each paragraph to make the reader need the next.
A second opinion on the plan
The planning page is where a second opinion helps most, because it's still cheap to change. Offo, a notebook for iPad that writes back, is built for exactly this kind of page. Sketch your one sentence and your boxes, send them, and ask Offo to push back the way your most sceptical listener would, or to tell you what's missing. Then redraw the boxes before you've written a word.
Questions people ask
How do I outline an essay?
Write your main claim as one sentence, list the questions a reader will ask in the order they'll ask them, and turn each question into a section with one piece of evidence or example. Then check that every section supports the main claim.
What's the best structure for a presentation?
It depends on your audience and goal. Answer-first suits busy audiences; problem-then-solution suits proposals; a story suits keynotes; alternating between what is and what could be suits talks that ask people to change.
How many main points should a talk have?
Fewer than you think. Listeners can't re-read, so three main points is plenty for most talks, each with one clear example.
How long should I spend planning a talk?
Longer than feels comfortable. A page of planning often saves hours of rewriting, because it's much easier to move boxes on a page than paragraphs in a draft.
Sources
- Minto, B. The Pyramid Principle: Logic in Writing and Thinking. Pearson.
- Duarte, N. (2010). Resonate: Present Visual Stories that Transform Audiences. Wiley.