Writing
How to find and fix plot holes in your story
Every draft has them: the moment a character knows something they couldn't, or doesn't do the obvious thing. The good news is that most plot holes can be fixed with a small change, once you've found them.
The short answer
A plot hole is a gap or contradiction in a story's logic: something happens that the story's own facts, rules or characters can't explain. To find them, reduce your draft to one line per scene, check that each scene happens because of the last one, and track who knows what, and when. Most plot holes can be fixed with a small change: set something up earlier, give a character a reason, add an obstacle, or cut the thing that breaks.
- Outline the draft you wrote, not the one you planned.
- Link scenes with “therefore” and “but”, not “and then”.
- Track what each character knows, and when they learn it.
- Fix with the smallest change that works.
What is a plot hole?
A plot hole is a place where a story contradicts itself or stops making sense on its own terms. A character is in two places at once. A rule the story set up gets quietly broken. Someone makes a choice that only makes sense because the plot needs it.
Not every unexplained thing is a plot hole. A mystery is a gap the story wants you to notice and promises to fill. A plot hole is a gap the story hopes you won't notice.
Six common kinds of plot hole
- Contradictions. Facts that change: eye colours, dates, how many people were in the car. Small, but readers notice.
- The “why don't they just…?” problem. The conflict only exists because nobody does the obvious thing: calls the police, asks the question, opens the letter. Roger Ebert called this the Idiot Plot: a plot that would be solved instantly if the characters weren't idiots.
- Impossible knowledge. A character knows something they had no way of finding out, or forgets something they obviously know.
- Broken rules. Your world's magic, technology or politics works one way in chapter three and another way when the plot needs it to.
- Dropped threads. A set-up with no pay-off, or a pay-off with no set-up. Chekhov's famous advice was that a gun on the wall in the first act should go off by the last. The reverse matters too: a gun shouldn't go off if nobody saw it on the wall.
- Timeline trouble. Journeys that take no time, a pregnancy that lasts a year, a week with three Fridays.
How to find plot holes in your draft
Make a reverse outline
Once you have a draft, list every scene in one line: who, what happens, what changes. You're outlining the book you actually wrote, not the one you planned. Holes are much easier to see in twenty lines than in two hundred pages.
Check the links: “therefore” and “but”
Matt Stone and Trey Parker, the creators of South Park, have a rule for their writers' room: the beats of a story should be joined by “therefore” or “but”, never “and then”. Read down your reverse outline and put one of the three between each scene. Every “and then” deserves a look. It often marks a scene that happens because you needed it to, not because the story caused it.
Track who knows what
Make a grid: characters down the side, key facts along the top, and in each square the scene where that character learns that fact. Impossible knowledge jumps out, and so do characters who should have said something and didn't.
Sketch the timeline
Draw a line and put every event on it: journeys, ages, seasons, days of the week. Timeline holes are nearly invisible in prose and obvious on a line.
Interrogate your antagonist
Ask whoever opposes your hero why they're doing what they're doing, and why this way. If the honest answer is “because the plot needs them to”, you've found a hole.
Get fresh eyes
You know what you meant, so you read the draft as you meant it. A reader who doesn't will trip over the gaps you can't see.
Your pageAct 2: Maya finds the letter in the attic
then confronts Dad then Dad leaves town
Offo writes backI tripped on the attic. If the letter's been up there for twenty years and your dad knows what's in it, why hasn't he burned it? Either he wants it found, which is a much more interesting dad, or someone else put it there. Which one is your story?
How to fix a plot hole
Most holes don't need a rewrite. Try the smallest fix first.
- Plant it earlier. If the ending relies on a skill, an object or a fact, show it before it's needed. One sentence in chapter two can save your climax.
- Give a reason. Why doesn't she just call the police? Maybe she did, last time, and it went badly. A line of motivation turns a hole into character.
- Add an obstacle. If the obvious solution would end the story, take it away: the phone's dead, the bridge is out, the one person who knows is lying.
- Acknowledge it. Sometimes a character noticing the oddness (“Why would anyone leave the key here?”) is enough. Screenwriters call this hanging a lantern on it.
- Change who knows what. Move the moment someone learns a fact, and the hole often closes by itself.
- Cut it. If a scene or subplot causes more holes than it's worth, let it go. Arthur Quiller-Couch's advice to writers was blunter: “Murder your darlings.”
Sketch your plot to see the holes
Plot holes hide in prose and show up in pictures. A page with your timeline along the bottom, your characters as circles and arrows for cause and effect will show you in a minute what three read-throughs missed: the arrow that points nowhere, the character who vanishes for five chapters, the event with no cause. (Our guide to sketching to think has simple shapes to use.)
On an iPad you get one extra advantage: you can keep the whole map of the book on one page, and zoom in on a single chapter when you need to.
Write your story's scenes as a single column of one-liners. Between each pair, write “therefore”, “but” or “and then”. Circle every “and then”, and ask what would have to change for it to become a “therefore”.
A reader who asks the awkward questions
Beta readers and writing groups are the traditional way to find holes: people who'll say “wait, how did she know that?”.
Offo, a notebook for iPad that writes back, is a reader you can ask at any hour. Sketch your plot, write out your scene list, or scribble down the bit that's bothering you, then send it. Offo replies on the page with the awkward question: the “why doesn't she just…?” you've been avoiding. It won't write your story for you, and it won't try to. The fixes, and the voice, stay yours.
Questions people ask
What's the difference between a plot hole and a mystery?
A mystery is a gap the story wants you to notice and promises to explain. A plot hole is a gap the story doesn't know it has: a contradiction or unexplained event that breaks its own logic.
Do plot holes matter if readers don't notice?
Small ones often don't. But readers notice more than writers expect, and a hole at a key moment, especially the ending, can undo their trust in the whole story.
Can AI find plot holes?
AI can help by asking questions about your plot, such as why a character doesn't do the obvious thing, or how someone knows what they know. It works best as a reader who questions, not a writer who rewrites.
How do I fix a plot hole without rewriting everything?
Try the smallest fix first: set the thing up earlier, give a character a reason, add an obstacle, have a character notice the oddness, or cut the scene that causes it.
Sources
- Ebert, R. Ebert's guide to practical filmgoing: a glossary of terms for the cinema of the '80s. RogerEbert.com.
- Stone, M. & Parker, T. (2011). Writing advice to an NYU film class, filmed for mtvU's Stand In.
- Quiller-Couch, A. (1916). On the Art of Writing. Cambridge University Press. (From his 1914 lecture “On Style”.)